From Championship Winners to Sore Losers

In partnership with

Picture this: You're the head coach of a powerhouse sports franchise.

Your star players (loyal customers) are killing it, the fan base (new customers) is growing, and those ticket sales (revenue) are looking sweeter than your grandma's famous apple pie.

But then, out of nowhere, your point guard (top customer) gets lured away by another team. Ouch. Suddenly, your shooting percentage (customer retention rate) is in the gutter.

To make matters worse, that slick new expansion team across town is poaching your most promising recruits (new customers). And if that wasn't enough, the hot dog vendor just doubled their prices, cutting into your all-important concessions revenue.

Sound familiar? That's the Growth Trilemma in a nutshell – the never-ending battle to keep your stars happy, attract fresh talent, and boost those revenue numbers, all at the same dang time.

It's like trying to dribble three balls at once while refereeing a game and managing the score($)board. Not an easy feat, my friend.

A few years back, I was knee-deep in this exact dilemma at a fast-growing startup. We had a killer product, but we were all over the place – trying to keep our existing customers happy, pushing for more sales, and attracting new ones.

It felt like coaching a team that was always on the brink of a championship but struggling to find the right balance on the field. We needed a game plan, and we needed it fast.

So, why does balancing these three elements matter so much? 

Too much focus on one area, and you could end up with a lopsided performance. Not enough attention, and your team falls apart. I've got a few plays straight from my playbook to help you master this trilemma once and for all.

Here's what we'll go through - grab your favorite mug and enjoy:

1. The role of each part of the trilemma

2. What happens when you overcommit

3. How the champs cracked the code

4. A game plan to find the perfect balance

The Role of Each Part of the Trilemma 

Just like any legendary team, a wildly successful business needs a balanced attack with three key components:

Retention: Your Franchise Players

These are your MVPs, your tried-and-true starters that you can always count on to show up and ball out.

In business terms, they're your loyal, high-value customers who keep coming back for more. Losing even them is a huge blow, so keeping them happy and engaged is priority number one.

Revenue Growth: The Offensive Gameplan

While keeping your star players is crucial, you've also got to have a killer strategy for putting points on the board (i.e. increasing revenue).

Just like the greats - Pat Riley's 'Seven Seconds or Less' offense or Bill Belichick's situational game-planning mastery - you need to continually optimize your processes, refine your strategies, and find new ways to grow those sales numbers.

Customer Growth: The Draft Picks

Any coach worth their whistle knows you can't just rely on your current roster forever. You've got to keep replenishing that talent pipeline by scouting and recruiting the hottest prospects (new customers) out there.

Having a steady stream of fresh faces ensures your team stays dynamic, competitive, and doesn't get stale over time.

Neglect any one of these areas, and your championship dreams will start unraveling faster than a cheap basketball. Let me illustrate with a few cautionary tales from the sports history books.

What Happens When You Overcommit

Alright, now that we've gone over the basics of balancing the Growth Trilemma, it's time for a little tough love. Let's take a look at what can happen when a team gets overzealous and starts leaning way too hard into just one aspect of the trilemma:

The Branding-Obsessed Cowboys

For many years after their 90s dynasty, the Dallas Cowboys became more focused on marketing, merchandising, and pure revenue generation than winning on the field.

They let their recruiting and coaching strategies fall by the wayside as they chased sponsorship dollars and media hype.

The results?

While still one of the most profitable franchises around, the Cowboys' on-field performance has been extremely inconsistent and playoff appearances have been few and far between.

When you neglect your coaching gameplan and player development, even the biggest brand in sports can't buy you championships.

The "Trust the Process" 76ers

In the 2010s, the Philadelphia 76ers executed a drastic rebuilding strategy dubbed "The Process."

They decided to go all-in on recruiting young talent through the draft, sacrificing wins in the short-term to stock up on high picks. Veteran players were traded away or allowed to leave as free agents.

While they did eventually land future stars like Joel Embiid and Ben Simmons, those first few "Process" years were some ugly basketball. With no experienced mentors and an revolving door of rookies, Philly became the laughing stock of the league.

It took years to finally build a competitive team around their young core once they rebalanced their approach.

The Star-Chasing Knicks

Then there's the case of the 90s-2000s New York Knicks.

Rather than continually injecting new talent, they became obsessed with paying big money to retain their fading stars from their earlier playoff runs like Patrick Ewing and Alan Houston. Huge contracts were handed out with little regard for the future or restocking the roster.

With no fresh faces and an aging core, the Knicks went from playoff contenders to a decade of irrelevance and losing records. Sometimes you have to know when to let stars go and refocus your efforts on drafting and developing the next generation of talent.

The lesson? 

You've got to be constantly juggling your retention strategies (keeping those franchise players happy), revenue optimization (designing that unstoppable offensive gameplan), and customer acquisition (scouting for those blue-chip recruits).

It's a delicate balancing act, but one that championship-caliber teams like the Patriots and Mercedes F1 have mastered.

Speaking of which…

How the Champs Cracked the Code

When it comes to mastering the Growth Trilemma, we can take a play or two from some of sports' most dominant dynasties. Let's break down how they unlocked that perfect balance:

Mercedes F1 Team (2014-2020)

This high-octane squad won a staggering 7 constructors' and 7 drivers' championships in a row from 2014-2020 by firing on all cylinders:

Retention: 

The team's cornerstone was keeping eng-DRIVERS like Lewis Hamilton in the cockpit year after year. Mercedes created an environment that rewarded elite talent, providing top-tier technology, support staff, and facilities to make their superstars feel valued.

Revenue: 

The Mercedes AMG cars were true revenue-generating machines on the track.

Their vehicles integrated the latest cutting-edge designs, hybrid technologies, and engineering breakthroughs to ensure they had the fastest and most advanced cars on the grid.

This dominance attracted lucrative sponsorships from blue-chip brands like Petronas, AMD, and IWC.

Recruitment: 

But Mercedes never rested on their laurels.

They operated a disciplined scouting and recruitment program to onboard the most promising young engineers, technicians and drivers.

Up-and-comers like George Russell were carefully integrated to learn from the established talent.

By balancing all three areas, Mercedes built a juggernaut that broke numerous F1 records, posting 109 wins and 118 poles over that 7-year span. 

Not too shabby for a team that was a mid-field contender at most just a few years prior.

New England Patriots (2001-2019)

Although I'm a Falcons fan (don't get me started on the 2017 Super Bowl), we can't ignore the dominant Patriots who won 6 Super Bowl titles and appeared in 9 championship games during this 18-year stretch under Bill Belichick's guidance.

Retention: 

The core philosophy? Retain key veterans and foundational talents like Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski to create an environment players don't want to leave.

By rewarding performance, providing top-notch coaching, and cultivating a true team culture, the Pats kept their championship nucleus intact for over a decade.

Revenue: 

Playoff appearances and titles drove fan engagement through the roof in New England. The Patriots leaned into their on-field dominance, setting revenue records for merchandise sales, ticket prices, corporate sponsorships, you name it.

With the championships came financial windfalls that were reinvested into the product.

Recruitment: 

But the team was constantly refreshing their roster through judicious drafting and free agent acquisitions. Promising prospects like Devin McCourty got to learn from the established vets.

The "next man up" mentality meant new recruits were seamlessly integrated into the winning culture right away.

Thanks to this balanced approach, the Patriots built the second dynasty of the 21st century with 17 division titles and over $4 billion in revenue from 2002-2019. 

Not bad for an off-the-radar franchise that was once a joke just a couple decades prior, huh?

So how can you replicate that coaching excellence? I'm glad you asked…

Your 4th Quarter Game Plan

I wish the Falcons have read this newsletter in 2017 and attempted the damn field goal 🤡.

Jokes aside, let's dive into it:

Assess Your Roster: 

Before making any moves, take a hard look at where your team is at currently.

Are you stacked with loyal superstars but struggling to find new talent?

Or are you flash with new recruits but hemorrhaging revenue? An honest evaluation of your strengths and weaknesses is crucial.

Study the Stats: 

Don't just go by gut instinct here. Dig into the data and KPIs to identify your biggest areas for improvement. Maybe your customer satisfaction scores are dipping, or your new customer acquisition is stagnant. Let the numbers guide your gameplan.

Make Strategic Adjustments

Retention Plays: 

Implement loyalty programs, ramp up customer support, surprise and delight them - do whatever it takes to make your star players feel loved and appreciated. Losing even one MVP is a big ouch.

Revenue Boosters: 

Optimize pricing, streamline operations, explore new revenue streams. Like the Pats' evolving gameplan from week-to-week, never stop tinkering to increase those sales numbers.

Recruitment Drives: 

Launch referral programs, amp up marketing, improve the customer experience. Do whatever it takes to get top rookie talent into your pipeline and onto the squad.

Review and Recalibrate

Guess what, coach?

This isn't a "set it and forget it" kind of thing. You need to be constantly reviewing those metrics, surveying the competitive landscape, and recalibrating your strategies as needed.

Those other teams aren't just sitting around either!

So lace up those coaching kicks and get ready to sprint up and down that sideline. 

The Growth Trilemma is one heckuva challenge, but by balancing retention, revenue, and recruitment strategies like a maestro, you'll have your business firing on all cylinders in no time!

Who's ready to start drawing up some championship-level growth plays? This could be our year, team! Let's run it back!

60,000 world-class marketers read this newsletter daily

Marketers at Google, Tesla, Meta, Shopify, Amazon, Pinterest, Meta, and other successful companies, read Stacked Marketer to increase their IQ.

Stacked Marketer curates the most useful and important digital marketing news, trends, strategies, and case studies and boils it down to a 7-minute read.

It’s 100% free. And you can sign up here.

🛠 My Favorite Tools

🌎 Remote Work Toolkit →

💰Marketing and Sales Tools →

🤓 What I'm into right now

📺 What I'm Watching

The second of season of Reacher. Any recommendations for my next series or movie?

🎧 What I'm Listening

June is “São João” month in Brazil 🇧🇷, so I'm listening to a lot of typical musics from the June festivities. Here's a great album if you want a taste of Brazil.

🎮 What I'm Playing

Currently playing Hogwarts Legacy on the PS4. You have to play if you are fan of the Harry Potter franchise.